Sher Bahadur Deuba Against Constituent Assembly Election: Why?

There is a saying in Nepali: Ikh nabhayeko chhora ra bikh nabhayeko sarpa ekai hun [A son without resolve and snake without poison are same (or useless)]. Sher Bahadur Deuba, the former Prime Minister and president of Nepali Congress (Democratic), is a perfect example. He is speaking against the election of Constituent Assembly and indirectly helping the king.

By Dinesh Wagle

The king kicked on his face several times but Deuba never stops acting like a loyal royal slave. And he always talks in such a way that would be beneficial to the king. [King Gyanendra sacked Deuba from the post of Prime Minister branding him “incompetent” to hold the general election in 2004 and, again in 2005, put him in house arrest in 2005 after sacking from the same post of PM.] After the royal coup of Feb 2005, Sher Bahadur Deuba was vocally against the king (or monrchy) though there were some people who used to say that this man could do the U turn at anytime. They used to cite Deuba’s pro-royal activities, including accepting royal awards which have been traditionally declined Nepali Congress leaders for decades. It seems those skeptics are going to be correct. Deuba has started showing the sing of U turn. Yesterday he talked against the possibility of election of Constituent Assembly on time (by June). He thinks the security situation is too bad to hold an election and says eight parties [ruling alliance and the Maoist] should unanimously agree to reschedule the election program. Talking to journalists at his party’s headquarters in Maharajgunj, Deuba said: “In light of the recent incidents in the country, the voters are in no position to cast their votes in a fear-free environment.” How can an ‘incompetent’ Deuba say so? For him, the security situation wasn’t favorable even in 2004 and, when he tried to push the election dates, faced royal sacking. Now, the same guy is talking about pushing the election to uncertainty on the pretext of same old reason.

Yes, security situation is not good in Nepal these days. Even the Prime Minister has accepted this harsh reality. But it’s not bad in all areas. The situation is challenging mainly in a few districts in southern Nepal. There is no security problem in hilly and mountainous districts. No problem in many other districts in Terai itself. Some, including the election commission, say there are not enough staffs and security personnel for the election. Why not go for options like holding election in phases? The most promising aspect is that Prime Minister Girija Prasad Koirala is committed to holding election in time. He said so in his recent meeting with the election commissioner which was attended by all leaders including Prachanda of the Maoist, Madhav Kumar Nepal of CPN UML and Deuba. Deuba expressed negativism on the prospects of election in that meeting as well where as Koirala, Nepal and Prachanda firmly committed themselves towards the democratic process. (Today MK Nepal said that “worsening law and order situation has overshadowed the election issue”. This statement from his is intended at pressurizing the government than trying to push the election to uncertainty.) The only person supporting Deuba in the meeting was Surya Bahadur Thapa (of Rastriya Janashakti Party.) Thapa recently came heavily against democratic development. It’s not hard to see the anti-election nexus that is slowly growing.

The main point is we should not push the election of Constituent Assembly on any pretext. We have the history, very bitter, about not being able to hold the CA election. And the king took advantage of that situation in the 50s. There was no effective pressure for CA election at that time because, as I read somewhere, the CA election issue was only raised by the parties at that time. Today situation is different. People want constituent assembly. The whole country has made the CA election the main agenda. When the whole country is ready to caste vote, the masked efforts from people like Deuba to derail the election plan must be countered effectively. In the past few days Nepali Congress general secretary Ram Chandra Poudel has also hinted that the process of election couldn’t be finished by the end of Jestha meaning that the process could be extended for weeks. That can be accepted but I see some problem with Deuba statement. He isn’t honest. I see some kind of conspiracy in his remarks. It is a known fact that the palace wants to stop the election of the assembly that will decide the fate of monarchy with a simple majority. It’s almost certain that the assembly will vote to eradicate the feudal institution from Nepal. Even a child understands why palace wants to stop the election.

The Constituent Assembly is not just for dealing with monarchy in Nepal. It’s about drafting the new future plans for the country. It’s about restructuring the state, empowering various groups and ethnic/marginalized communities and bringing them to the mainstream of Nepali ruling. That is why all efforts must be focused on making the election of Constituent Assembly a reality.






61 responses to “Sher Bahadur Deuba Against Constituent Assembly Election: Why?”

  1. Dhana Rai - UK Avatar
    Dhana Rai – UK

    Dinesh Wagle bhai,

    I am from Pokhara. I am 54 years old retired man living in UK with my son and grand-children.

    I have seen the east and the west. One value that is so common amongst different civilization is the courage to speak the honest truth – that courage to speak the honest truth is what differentiates a man from a boy. I have taught that value to my sons when they were little boys and now to my grand-children who are little boys.

    I am assuming that through your blog you are trying to share your little views and meekly assert that your have graduated to manhood from boyhood through various stages of maturity. Have you?

    I am compelled to write today that I am not convinced. I have seen time after time your concerted and vicious effort to spread lies after lies after lies. I deeply wonder why?

    The only answer I can conclude is that you have an agenda ridden axe to grind and that agenda seems to be “by hook or crook” or “by deceit or lies” or “by any low level means possible” perpetuate your biased and error ridden logic to your readers who have kindly taken time out of their busy schedule to read your blog.

    Don’t compel this pahade-dai of your’s to believe that you are low life and a no good liar. I want to believe that you are better than that as I have believed of my all Nepali-bhais. Are you or are you not?

    You know – liars not only get crucified in this life but there is no mercy in after life either.

    Through this discourse, I hope that your soul gets liberated !!!!

  2. bajra Avatar

    Dhana Rai
    u r good. i can understand what u r saying, but i still won’t trust this wagle even he is gonna write truth. this guys is full of shit. Do u still remember that proverb ” Bara barsha ……kukur ko puchare ………….”
    i hope u understand what m i saying.

  3. NepalBlood Avatar

    Wagle is a Biralo Bahun

  4. Patriot Avatar

    Initially I thought Wagle was naturally incompetent – hence all the carelesness, but again one cant be that stupid all the time. I have learnt much about Nepal and its problems only in the last one year or so but I think I have a fair understanding of what our real problems are. Wagle’s consistent one-sided views come across as extremely biased and stink of hidden agenda all over.

  5. manan Avatar

    Dhana Rai, Bajra, NepalBlood,

    If you have something specific to say, please go forward and say it. But don’t accuse on the basis of generalities. I don’ t agree with Wagle often, but I single out the points. ( Not that he addresses them, but hey, its his forum. He has the right to do what he wants to).

    Its childish to complain, but give no indication as to what you’re complaining about.

  6. comrade Bhayankar Avatar
    comrade Bhayankar

    We want to hold the CA elections in a rush. Our party’s chances of winning elections in a chaotic situation is better than in a normal, fear free situation. Now lets say somehow we lose the elections. Then we can always protest against the results and launch a movement to cancel it saying that the election was unfair since there were so many flaws in the interim constituition and that the elections was not done well. In any case, you guys cannot stop us. In addition to that we have support from young journalists like our Wagle bhai. We are unstoppable. You guys better start keeping quiet and supporting us otherwise…

  7. B Avatar


    If this is wagle’s forum, his personal property and can do what ever he wants with it, Can he advertise, cigarrettes or whiskey on this site? Look, with democratic rights come some responsibilities and obligations which no one can ignore.

  8. ying yang Avatar
    ying yang

    No wonder the likes of Wagle talk about loktrantra and democracy but seem to miserably fail to uphold the basic idea- a true Bhaun Character. By the way Manan- Democracy means responsibility as well not only rights, better learn it. And also Mr. Rai is saying which is quiet obvious to us, why not you? Or you blind as bat not to get the drift.

  9. manan Avatar

    Ying yang,

    Yes, “I’m blind as bat”. So explain to me what’s so obvious to you and Mr. Rai.

  10. Bhudai Pundit Avatar
    Bhudai Pundit

    ying yang you need a good slap across your face (the kind that leaves a handprint) for again bring up caste issues. You scum. get over this and move on otherwise people like you will plunge Nepal into an even more chaotic situation.

  11. sunit Avatar

    ya now see the rulling party of nepal it is worse than ever before so i like nepal to be royal not baun country coz baun will do something there will be no more nepal in world.

%d bloggers like this: